Thursday, 23 January 2014

Is there a contrast between the truth of our lives and the story that we tell?


You know Hunter typed ‘The Great Gatsby’? He'd look at each page Fitzgerald wrote, and he copied it. The entire book. And more than once. Because he wanted to know what it felt like to write a masterpiece. He was so hungry, yeah. Innocent, and yearning.
 -- Johnny Depp on Hunter S. Thompson

We all have our idols, and the thing that has always gotten to me about these famous individuals is the autonomous nature of them. Their tale is often one of an underdog story in which they face diversity. Hunter S. Thompson actively fought authoritarianism, Emily Dickinson passively fought gender inequality, and J.K. Rowling fought poverty at the hands of a Conservative government.

What have I fought?


I haven’t fought gender inequality, homophobia or any war. I am turning twenty-one this year and in a generation of smart phones and social media I have passively sat back like the rest of us. Sure, I’ve read a book or two but I’ve seen no Punk movement. No revolutions. I have no historical life experience if not for this realm of perpetual monotony.

I, like them, am a victim of circumstance

While I do believe there is a link, I sincerely hope – for my sake at least – that there isn’t a contrast between the truth of our lives and the stories that we tell.

We all die. The goal isn't to live forever, the goal is to create something that will. 
-- Chuck Palahniuk

3 comments:

  1. Interesting post! The idea of truth in stories, particularly your last point about having lived through no particularly interesting periods, for me raises the question of whether you should indeed only write what you know. If you don't then are you lying, or just being creative?

    ReplyDelete
  2. I thought exactly the same thing when we spoke in lecture about the obstacles that both Dickinson and Cheever faced: I HAVE FACED NO TRAUMA, SEEN NO WARS NOR REVOLUTION! But that doesn't make the themes of my writing any less interesting, does it? I'd like to think not, we're still young, we have a whole life of experience ahead of us.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Whenever any of these blog questions focus primarily on me as a person, on what I have experienced and what has influenced me, I tend to shy away, because I don't find myself interesting. Like you, I wouldn't say I've experienced any real trauma of lived through any historical revolutions. But as with any kind of writing, we're too close to it to think objectively about it quite yet. In terms of history, every moment of it is important and we're all cogs in the machine that keeps it turning. We're all effected by the society, time and era that we live in, but we haven't had any time to look back on it and see it as important quite yet.

    ReplyDelete